Passing of Accounts and Court Costs

Passing of Accounts and Court Costs

Re Rodgers Estate 2017 BCSC 2001 discussed who should bear the costs of a passing of accounts hearing where it was asserted that no valid complaints were raised re the accounting by the party challenging them. The court ultimately held that the estate should bear… Read more

Special Costs in S 58 WESA Application | Disinherited

Special Costs In S 58 WESA Application

Re: Hadley Estate 2017 BCCA 311 the BC Appeal court upheld the principle of costs in estate litigation where the litigation is necessary due to the conduct of the deceased, then each party will normally be entitled to have their legal fees paid for from… Read more

Executor Personally Liable For Court Costs

Executor Personally Liable For Court Costs

Craven v Osdacz 2017 ONSC 4396 held an executor of an estate personally liable for costs totalling about $150,000 for reckless and unreasonable behavior that amounted to reprehensible for opposing a plaintiff’s court action for no valid reason other than to frustrate and delay the… Read more

Offers to Settle and Double Cost Awards

Offers to Settle and Double Costs

Connor Estate 2017 BCSC 1341 dealt with the issue of whether the plaintiff should be  awarded double costs after the filing of an offer to settle that the plaintiff beat at the trial. The issue was whether the plaintiff Chambers was a spouse of the… Read more

Summary of Special Costs Awarded by the Court

Summary of Special Costs

When one litigant is ordered to pay all or most of the other  litigants legal fees it is an award of special costs, and Siemens v Howard 2017 BCSC 1193 is a good summary of when the court will award special costs. The single standard… Read more

Ordering Court Costs Against a Non-Party

Ordering Court Costs Against a Non-Party

Hollander v Mooney 2017 BCCA 238 discussed the Court’s jurisdiction to order costs against a non-party and held that it is limited to special circumstances such as fraudulent conduct, abuse of process, gross misconduct, or circumstances where the non-party is the “real litigant”: Anchorage Management… Read more

costs against lawyers

Personal Court Costs Against Lawyers

C.A.S. of the R.M.of W. v C.T.and J.B. 2017 ONSC 318 awarded personal court costs of $100,000 against a lawyer for her role in a custody battle involved in the Children’s Aid Society. The court found that the lawyer’s tactics and strategy had caused an… Read more

Costs: The Standard of Review

Costs: The Standard of Review

The BC Court of Appeal in Giles v Westminster Savings Credit Union 2010 BCCA 282 reviewed the standard of awarding costs and the various purposes for an award of costs. The case was recently followed in Kyle Estate v Kyle 2017 BCSC 752 which stated… Read more

Offers to settle double costs

Offers to Settle Double Costs

Sim v Sim estate 2017 BCSC 345 discussed offers to settle and rejected an award for double costs finding that the offer was one that ought not to have reasonably been accepted as it required the plaintiff to give up the claim entirely while providing… Read more

Special Costs Not to Include Pre Litigation Conduct

Special Costs Not to Include Pre Litigation Conduct

The BC Appeal court in Smithies Holdings Inc. v. RCV Holdings Ltd., 2017 BCCA  extensively reviewed the law relating to an award of special costs and held that reprehensible pre litigation conduct should not be included when a judge exercises his or her discretion  as to award… Read more

Double Costs: Rule 9-1(5)

Double Costs: Rule 9-1(5)

The plaintiff’s claim was dismissed with costs and the defendant sought double costs under Rule 9-1(5) on the basis that the defendant made an offer to settle that should have been accepted by the plaintiff. The application for double costs was dismissed as the court… Read more

Court Costs Awarded Against Lawyer Personally

Court Costs Awarded Against Lawyer Personally

The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed an appeal of the Ontario Court of Appeal upholding a a substantial award of court costs against a  lawyer personally for his handling of a case found to be vexatious and an abuse of process.  The client was also jointly… Read more

Wills Variation and Court Costs

Wills Variation and Court Costs

Two recent wills variation cases awarded the usual order of court costs to a winning party, namely Scale B. In Dakin v Patry 2016 BCSC 1006 a plaintiff won a summary  trial and was awarded scale B . In Ciarniello v James 2016 BCSC 1805 the… Read more

Taxation of a Lawyers Account

Taxation of a Lawyers Account

Lawyer client relationships sometimes go off the rails and a dispute may arise about an unpaid account. The remedy is taxation of the account before a registrar of the Supreme  Court and both the client and the lawyer have the right to have the matter… Read more

Quantifying Special Costs and Contingency Fees

Quantifying Special Costs and Contingency Fees

Norris v Burgess 2016 BCSC 1451 stated the law for quantifying special costs and then applied that amount towards the plaintiff’s contingency fees. Norris was an ICBC case where the judge in a Jury trial found fault on the insurer for the late production of… Read more