UBC Property Transfer Set Aside For Being a “Fraud On a Power”

Fraud On a Power It is a fraud on a power contained in a will to use a society created in accordance with the terms of the will to achieve indirectly the transfer of property to a non-object of that power which could not be done… Read more

Appeal Court Disapproves Using Assessments To Value Property

Assessments To Value Property Dosanjh v Liang  2015 BCCA 18 disapproved of the use of using assessments to value property and prove damages in it’s valuation, and that the better practice is to use appraisers, especially for historical valuations. Here are excerpts paragraphs 57-70 that discus… Read more

Inheritance In Trust Taken By Trustee In Bankruptcy

A bankruptcy can over ride an inheritance, even when the inheritance is left in trust as per Bolt Estate 2014 BCSC 2095   A trust in a will provided that the un discharged bankrupt heir,  was to receive 1/4 of the capital at 26, the… Read more

The Differences Between Joint Bank Account and Joint Property

There are some particular features of a joint bank account that distinguish it from a joint tenancy in real property and these have been discussed by our Court of Appeal (Bergen v. Bergen, 2013 BCCA 492): ( see my blog on Bergen dated August 26.14… Read more

Courts Scrutinize Claims Against Estates

Claims Against Estates To Be Scrutinized   Miller v Miller ( 1987) 14 BCLR (2d) 42 at pa 451, and approved by other cases such as Friak v Pilon 2012 BCSC 528 state that claims against deceased persons must be approached by the courts ”… Read more

Disinherited.Com Likes Contingency Fee Cases

  A contingency fee basis agreement is a fee arrangement between a lawyer and client were typically the lawyer only receives a fee from the successful monies collected from a court action, with the usual motto being” no collection, no fees”. Such an arrangement is… Read more

Appeal Test For Reviewing Trials By Affidavit (Summary Trial)

Appeal Test For Reviewing a Summary trial   Lorintt v Boda 2014 BCCA 354 deals inter alia with the appeal test, the court uses when reviewing a trial where no oral evidence was give, but instead it was a summary trial based on affidavits. One… Read more

Removal of a Notice of Intention to Dispute Under WESA

Re Richardson Estate 2014 BCSC 2162 also dealt with the new WESA rules relating to the removal of a Notice of Intention to Dispute ( the former probate caveat), finding that the test is whether it is in the best interests of the estate to… Read more

Wills Variation and Resulting Trust Claims May Be Tried Together

For over 30 years I have pleaded Wills Variation claims together with Resulting Trust claims in the same case, only to be told by various defence counsel that the pleadings cannot be tried together at the same time.   When challenged, no one has ever… Read more

Party v Party Court Costs

Party v Party Court Costs   Semenoff Estate v Bridgeman 2014 BCSC 1845 involves the Court’s approach to assessing costs against a plaintiff who acted for himself personally in a nine day trial that was dismissed with costs for part of the trial and double costs… Read more

The Standard of Review By Appeal Courts of Lower Court’s Decisions

The BCCA in Re Korol 2014 BCCA 380 recently examined the standard of review of an appellate court of a lower court’s decision in light of the following  SCC case of Penner v Niagara Regional   An Appeal Court’s standard of review of discretionary decisions… Read more

Certificates of Pending Litigation (CPL’s) To Tie Up land

Certificates of Pending Litigation REPRINTED FROM CARSWELLS NOTES AND RELATING TO ONTARIO LAW ( SIMILAR  BUT NOT IDENTICAL TO BC LAW)   “Certificates of pending litigation (or lis pendens) (“CPL”) are often-used tool in order to preserve real property and unregistered interests in such property. The test… Read more

Appeal Court Allows Trusts to Be Interpreted re Their Meaning

BC Appeal Court have jurisdiction to construe a Trust Deed. See Donovan W.M. Waters, Mark R. Gillen and Lionel D. Smith, Waters’ Law of Trusts in Canada, 4th Ed. (Toronto: Thompson Reuters, 2012) at 1165-66. See also Engelman v. Engelman (1986), 23 E.T.R. 30 (B.C.C.A.) at… Read more

Executor’s Obligation to Disclose Documents In Estate Litigation

 Executor’s Obligation to Disclose Documents In Estate Litigation   Wang v Christie Estate 2014 BCSC 1574 confirms and discusses what I would have considered to be trite law in that once an executor named as a respondent in a civil wills variation claim is served… Read more

Court Determines Rights Between Two Competing Powers of Attorney Spouse vs Daughter

Powers of Attorney Spouse vs Daughter   Sommerville v Sommerville 2014 BCSC 1848 involved a court application wherein the deceased gave both his surviving widow and his daughter separate powers of attorney that could be used individually. The facts are somewhat complicated given that the… Read more